We have come to the end of the semester here at the Las
Cruces Biological Station. The last week has been primarily centered on the
research of all the different groups. Due to the slowing down of the semester,
the only reasonable topic to bring up is the research itself! Our group was
tasked with the topic of “plant-based soaps.” Our instructions were to find
local plants that contain chemicals called saponins, and see if they could be
used to replace typical soap. Saponins are thought to be the main ingredient
that allows the dirt and bacteria to be swept off of your skin. Learning the
fact that saponins did not kill bacteria, but lifted and dragged the bacteria
off the skin, is what encouraged us to go with the technique of handwashing in
the lab.
On the same night we were assigned our task, we all sat
together hypothesizing about how we would test our new ideas. We concluded that
we would use the plants to wash our
hands – the same way we would with soap. How would we check to see if this
worked? We would check bacterial growth on our hands from before washing and
after washing. We also wanted to use two controls to see how effective our
plants really were: Protex© antibacterial soap and plain tap water. Our plan
worked out well. We researched four plants: Phytolacca
rivinoides, Clidemia hirta, Yucca elephantipes, and PF (shown in the photo above) that are known to have high saponin
content and did exactly what we had planned (well… more or less). We washed our
hands with these plants and with the controls (sounds a lot simpler than it
actually was) and watched the bacteria grow…or not grow.
Our
results were surprising! None of the treatments worked better than any of the
others – meaning that none of the plants worked better than water, and neither
did the Protex© antibacterial soap (see chart below). The good thing is that
each of them did, indeed, decrease the bacterial load on our hands. The group
had to chalk-up our results to good handwashing technique and clean water as
the fundamental necessities when it comes to handwashing! Of course, there are
many implications in the lab that could have skewed our results and we have
plenty of ideas for future research.
It is a bittersweet moment, because a part of me is
relieved the semester is over, but another part of me would have really liked
to continue the research and answer the questions we now have. Perhaps, next
semester, a different group will pick up where we left off!